San Francisco officials, LGBT advocates, and attorneys
involved in the fight for marriage equality hailed today (Thursday, May 15) as
a "wonderful day" for all Californians in light of the state Supreme
Court's ruling that same-sex couples cannot be denied the right to marry.
At a noon event under the Rotunda of City Hall where LGBT
leaders, couples and allies had gathered on the grand staircase, Mayor Gavin
Newsom raised his right fist in victory as he walked to a podium set up at the
bottom of the stairs where more than 4,000 couples were married during February
and March of 2004.
"What a day in San Francisco! What a day for
equality! Who among us was prepared for this extraordinary moment and
extraordinary time," said Newsom, who cut short a trip to Washington, D.C.
to return home Wednesday night to await the court's ruling. "I can't tell
you how proud I am to be a San Franciscan."
"It's an affirmation of the gay and lesbian community
and an extraordinary day for all of us as Americans," Newsom told the Bay
Area Reporter in a Thursday phone call.
Fighting back tears Kate Kendell, executive director of the
National Center for Lesbian Rights, simply said, "We won!"
As she choked up, Kendell added, "There is not a LGBT
person in this country who is not better off because we won. The human family
is better off because we won."
Standing among the crowd was Mabel Teng, the former city
assessor-recorder who helped preside over the marriage ceremonies four years
ago and became a vocal supporter of marriage equality in the Chinese and Asian
American communities. It was Teng's first time back in City Hall since she
resigned from office in 2005 amid accusations of cronyism in her hiring
practices.
In an interview with the B.A.R.
Teng said she had been living in Hong Kong since
then but returned to San Francisco in March due to the court's taking up the
marriage case.
"This is a proud and happy moment to be back in City
Hall," said Teng as she joined in the victory celebration. "It's a
good battle to fight and a good battle to win."
Asked about the constitutional amendment banning gay
marriage expected to be on the November ballot, Teng predicted that "there
will be challenges, there will be legal battles" but that in the end
"there will be more victories."
Newsom said the Supreme Court's ruling is a win not just
for LGBT people but also for all citizens of the Golden State and that the
court's decision was long overdue. It was four years ago that Newsom ordered
city officials to marry same-sex couples, ushering in a legal struggle to see
that the state's antigay marriage laws be overturned.
"At the end of the day make no mistake, this day is
about real people and real lives. It is about people coming together as
families all across the state of California and allowing themselves to be fully
expressive," said Newsom, who dedicated the day to Phyllis Lyon and Del
Martin, the first couple to be married on the morning of February 12, 2004.
"Because that is where this started."
Newsom also said the decision is a victory for the
parents, grandparents, friends and families of LGBT people everywhere.
"It's about love, dignity, and civil rights. It's
about time," said a beaming Newsom, who has faced repeated criticism from
both anti-gay activists and some Democratic leaders for his pro-gay marriage
stance. "By the way, as California goes, so goes the rest of the
nation."
Amid thunderous applause Newsom added, "This is the
future and it is now."
City Attorney Dennis Herrera, who oversaw the city's legal
strategy in the two cases that stemmed out of Newsom's historic decision, said
his office knew the city had won because even in City Hall they could hear the
cheers of the crowd gathered outside the Supreme Court building across the
street.
"Geez, it's a warm day," joked Herrera.
"What a wonderful day."
Due to the court's "courageousness," Herrera
said, "We have taken a wonderful step forward."
He echoed a quote from slain civil rights leader Martin
Luther King Jr., who said, "The arc of history is long but it bends toward
justice."
"Let us cherish what is an incredibly historic day for
all Californians and people throughout this country," added Herrera.
During a conference call with reporters Thursday, Shannon
Minter, the legal director for the National Center for Lesbian Rights who
argued the case before the Supreme Court on behalf of 14 same-sex couples and
Equality California, the statewide LGBT advocacy group, commended the court for
its decision.
"As you can imagine this is a moment of pure happiness
and joy for so many families here in California today. We are so grateful to
the court," said Minter. "This is a powerful affirmation of love and
commitment. We are so proud of our court for standing up for fairness and
equality."
Therese Stewart, the chief deputy city attorney of San
Francisco who argued on behalf of the city, urged the community to defend the
court's stance, as it will be attacked by the right wing for siding with the
LGBT community.
"It is an era where courts around the country have been
under constant attack and many in other states have shrunk from their duty. Our
court remained true to its history. It applied the constitution today without
regard to politics or controversy," said Stewart. "It took a lot of
courage. The court will be criticized today by some people. We need to step up
and get involved in defending the independence of the judiciary.
"Today is a day to celebrate justice in the broadest
sense of the word and make sure we have a court where justice is served,"
added Stewart.
Supervisor Bevan Dufty, who took part in the City Hall
gathering, stood at the bottom of the staircase and in between smiles could be
seen frowning at times. He said while he was overjoyed by the court ruling he
was also saddened thinking about the recent death of Lawrence King, the Oxnard
teenager killed by a classmate because he was gay.
"I think it is a win for justice and a win for
California and a win for the future. I thought about the future generations of
young people who will be unfettered by knowing they can attain love and
marriage in their lives," said Dufty. "I also thought about Lawrence
King today, that was on my mind. I thought how tragic it is that in a time
where we have this watershed civil rights moment for the LGBT community at the
same time this 15-year-old boy can still be gunned down in his classroom for
being gay."